History
clear
    Most Popular
    • 🎄 Christmas
    • 👻 Halloween
    • 🔥 Blanket
    • ⚽ Soccer
    • 🔥 Special Deals
    • 🥎 Softball
    • Christmas Tree Ornament
    • Bookmark
    • ⛳ Golf
    • 🏐 Volleyball
    Trending Products
    Your Personal Blossom, Your Reading Charm - Personalized Name Magnetic Bookmark Clip
    Your Personal Blossom, Your Reading Charm - Personalized Name Magnetic Bookmark Clip
    (338)
    $13.00
    Mark Your Legacy for Golfers - Personalized Monogrammed Initial Name Golf Ball Stamp for Birthday Gift
    Mark Your Legacy for Golfers - Personalized Monogrammed Initial Name Golf Ball Stamp for Birthday Gift
    (1241)
    $28.00
    A Little Love Note from You Make Your Gifts Extra Special This Christmas - Personalized Waterproof Stickers
    A Little Love Note from You Make Your Gifts Extra Special This Christmas - Personalized Waterproof Stickers
    (34)
    $11.00
    This Is My Territory - Personalized Player Sports Hooded Blanket
    This Is My Territory - Personalized Player Sports Hooded Blanket
    (35)
    $39.00
    Your Christmas Magic Woven with Cheer - Personalized Name Jute Tote Bag
    Your Christmas Magic Woven with Cheer - Personalized Name Jute Tote Bag
    (43)
    $17.00
    Pack Your Journey Your Way - Personalized Birth Flower Nylon Travel Duffel Bag
    Pack Your Journey Your Way - Personalized Birth Flower Nylon Travel Duffel Bag
    (136)
    $33.00
    Personalized Cheerleading Cartoon Character Multicolor Soft Throw Blanket with Name Senior Night Game Day Team Gift for Cheerleaders Coaches
    Personalized Cheerleading Cartoon Character Multicolor Soft Throw Blanket with Name Senior Night Game Day Team Gift for Cheerleaders Coaches
    (159)
    $23.00
    My Kit Where Tools Meet Blooms - Personalized Hair Tools Travel Bag
    My Kit Where Tools Meet Blooms - Personalized Hair Tools Travel Bag
    (393)
    $33.00
    Embrace the Joy Your Favorite Girl - Personalized Cartoon Quirky Girl Throw Pillow Cover
    Embrace the Joy Your Favorite Girl - Personalized Cartoon Quirky Girl Throw Pillow Cover
    (553)
    $19.00
    Personalized Monogrammed Initial Name Golf Ball Multicolor Stamp Club Competition Souvenir Birthday Gift for Golf Lovers Golfers
    Personalized Monogrammed Initial Name Golf Ball Multicolor Stamp Club Competition Souvenir Birthday Gift for Golf Lovers Golfers
    (100)
    $28.00
    Suggestions
    Valentine's Day Gifts for Him

    Valentine's Day Gifts for Him
    Valentine's Day Gifts for Her

    Valentine's Day Gifts for Her
    Valentine's Gift for Both

    Valentine's Gift for Both
    Free Standard Shipping

    Free Standard Shipping
    Valentines Day Cards

    Valentines Day Cards
    His And Hers Gifts

    His And Hers Gifts
    Valentine's Day Necklace

    Valentine's Day Necklace
    Valentine's Day Bracelet

    Valentine's Day Bracelet
    Valentine's Day Apparel

    Valentine's Day Apparel
    Valentine's Day Pillow

    Valentine's Day Pillow
    Valentine's Day Socks

    Valentine's Day Socks
    Valentine's Day Mug

    Valentine's Day Mug
    Valentines Delivery Guaranteed

    Valentines Delivery Guaranteed
    Gifts for LGBT

    Gifts for LGBT
    Romance in Shapes

    Romance in Shapes
    Melodies of Affection

    Melodies of Affection
    Cupid's Arrow of Love

    Cupid's Arrow of Love
    Love Poem Gifts

    Love Poem Gifts
    Home / Valentine's Day / First Valentine's Day Gifts

    First Valentine's Day Gifts

    1501 Products
    Sort By: Relevancy
    Relevancy
    Price High To Low
    Price Low To High
    Best Selling
    Recommended
    Under $20
    $20 to $30
    $30 to $40
    Over $40
    Personalized Cubic Zircon Heart Shape Angel Wing Photo Locket Sterling Silver Necklace Anniversary Birthday Gift for Women
    Personalized Cubic Zircon Heart Shape Angel Wing Photo Locket Sterling Silver Necklace Anniversary Birthday Gift for Women
    (1298)
    $40.00
    My Whole World Spinning Around My Finger - Personalized Sterling Silver Heart Stacking Rings
    My Whole World Spinning Around My Finger - Personalized Sterling Silver Heart Stacking Rings
    (993)
    $29.00
    Personalized Magnetic Heart Matching Bracelets with Initial Anniversary Birthday Gift for Couple Lover
    Personalized Magnetic Heart Matching Bracelets with Initial Anniversary Birthday Gift for Couple Lover
    (0)
    $16.00
    Personalized Retro Floral Initial Design Soft Warm Tassel Scarf with Name Anniversary Birthday Gift for Women
    Personalized Retro Floral Initial Design Soft Warm Tassel Scarf with Name Anniversary Birthday Gift for Women
    (10)
    $23.00
    Personalized Colorful Birth Flower Bouquet Faux Cashmere Scarf Tassel Shawl with Name Winter Accessory Birthday Holiday Gift for Family Friend
    Personalized Colorful Birth Flower Bouquet Faux Cashmere Scarf Tassel Shawl with Name Winter Accessory Birthday Holiday Gift for Family Friend
    (8)
    $23.00
    Personalized Mr & Mrs Waterproof Wrapping Paper with Family Name and Date Bridal Shower Wedding Anniversary Gift for Couple Bride Bridegroom
    Personalized Mr & Mrs Waterproof Wrapping Paper with Family Name and Date Bridal Shower Wedding Anniversary Gift for Couple Bride Bridegroom
    (0)
    $18.00
    Personalized Birth Month Flower Hair Brush Mother's Day Bachelorette Party Birthday Gift for Women
    Personalized Birth Month Flower Hair Brush Mother's Day Bachelorette Party Birthday Gift for Women
    (8)
    $16.00
    Personalized Infinity Photo Projection Zircon Necklace with Heart Dainty Jewelry Anniversary Birthday Memorial Gift for Women
    Personalized Infinity Photo Projection Zircon Necklace with Heart Dainty Jewelry Anniversary Birthday Memorial Gift for Women
    (0)
    $28.00
    Personalized 1-2 Birthstones Cross Promise Ring with Engraved Name and Text Dainty Jewelry Birthday Anniversary Gift for Christian Men
    Personalized 1-2 Birthstones Cross Promise Ring with Engraved Name and Text Dainty Jewelry Birthday Anniversary Gift for Christian Men
    (0)
    $29.00
    Personalized Birth Flower Cartoon Character Corduroy Sanitary Napkin Storage Bag with Name Portable Travel Essentials Daily Use Gift for Women
    Personalized Birth Flower Cartoon Character Corduroy Sanitary Napkin Storage Bag with Name Portable Travel Essentials Daily Use Gift for Women
    (7)
    $18.00
    Personalized Colorful 3D Enamel Bubble Letter Name Necklace Minimalist Jewelry Birthday Gift for Friends Family
    Personalized Colorful 3D Enamel Bubble Letter Name Necklace Minimalist Jewelry Birthday Gift for Friends Family
    (3)
    $21.00
    Personalized 1-5 Family Birthstones Cuff Bracelet with Engraved Name Women's Jewelry Birthday Anniversary Mother's Day Gift for Mom Grandma
    Personalized 1-5 Family Birthstones Cuff Bracelet with Engraved Name Women's Jewelry Birthday Anniversary Mother's Day Gift for Mom Grandma
    (9)
    $28.00
    Personalized Heart Birthstones Infinity Ring with Engraved Names and Text Birthday Anniversary Engagement Gift for Women
    Personalized Heart Birthstones Infinity Ring with Engraved Names and Text Birthday Anniversary Engagement Gift for Women
    (3)
    $26.00
    Personalized Minimalist Family 2-8 Heart Shaped Birthstones Necklace with Engraved Names Mother's Day Birthday Gift for Women Mom
    Personalized Minimalist Family 2-8 Heart Shaped Birthstones Necklace with Engraved Names Mother's Day Birthday Gift for Women Mom
    (42)
    $25.00
    A Love Only Your Warmth Can Reveal - Personalized Hidden Heat-activated Photo Adjustable Braided Bracelet
    A Love Only Your Warmth Can Reveal - Personalized Hidden Heat-activated Photo Adjustable Braided Bracelet
    (71)
    $27.00
    Personalized Zircon Crescent Moon Star Necklace with Heart-Shaped Birthstone Exquisite Jewelry Christmas Birthday Gift for Girl Woman
    Personalized Zircon Crescent Moon Star Necklace with Heart-Shaped Birthstone Exquisite Jewelry Christmas Birthday Gift for Girl Woman
    (0)
    $25.00
    Personalized Love Knot Birthstones Cuff Bracelet with Engraved Name Birthday Anniversary Valentine's Day Gift for Women
    Personalized Love Knot Birthstones Cuff Bracelet with Engraved Name Birthday Anniversary Valentine's Day Gift for Women
    (4)
    $30.00
    Personalized Birth Flower Multicolor Mini PU Leather Coin Purse Makeup Bag with Name Travel Essential Birthday Annivesary Gift for Women
    Personalized Birth Flower Multicolor Mini PU Leather Coin Purse Makeup Bag with Name Travel Essential Birthday Annivesary Gift for Women
    (226)
    $16.00
    Personalized Penguin Necklace with Name Dainty Jewelry Birthday Anniversary Valentine's Day Gift for Women
    Personalized Penguin Necklace with Name Dainty Jewelry Birthday Anniversary Valentine's Day Gift for Women
    (6)
    $19.00
    Personalized Heart Birthstone Pendant Necklace with Name Dainty Jewelry Birthday Anniversary Gift for Women Girls
    Personalized Heart Birthstone Pendant Necklace with Name Dainty Jewelry Birthday Anniversary Gift for Women Girls
    (13)
    $23.00
    More
    -- End --
    ABOUT US
    About Callie Contact us Terms and Conditions Blog Customer Reviews Callie Coupons Sitemap
    CUSTOMER SERVICE
    FAQ Delivery & Shipping Returns Policy Privacy Policy Payment Methods Affiliate Program
    CONTACT US
    Messenger
    Email: support@callie.com
    24/7 Customer Support
    DOWNLOAD THE CALLIE APP
    Scan the QR code with your phone camera
    This site is protected by Trustwave's Trusted Commerce program
    Safety Assurance
    United States
    United States
    United States
    Canada
    Canada
    France
    France
    Germany
    Germany
    United Kingdom
    United Kingdom
    Australia
    Australia
    Italy
    Italy
    Netherlands
    Netherlands
    Spain
    Spain
    Ireland
    Ireland
    Norway
    Norway
    Finland
    Finland
    Sweden
    Sweden

    Copyright © 2017-2025, CALLIE All Rights Reserved.